Centennial of the LGBTQ+ rights movement in the U.S.

In these dark moments, more than ever we need to remember and celebrate the accomplishments and never forget the past, so here’s an excerpt from an article in LGBTQ Nation

The centennial celebration of the Society for Human Rights is also the centennial of the official movement for LGBTQ+ equality in the United States. 

The celebration reminds us of all the group has taught: to gather in community, to help in community, to organize in community. As LGBTQ+ history is removed from curriculums as part of a broad anti-LGBTQ+ movement, organizations like Bell’s and Wilson’s continue to share our heritage outside of state-sanctioned channels.

“We are grounded in the present moment only when we understand the moments of the past,” Wilson said. “Understanding history empowers us to stand our ground and to advance the causes that others, like Henry Gerber, began advancing long ago. Historical literacy is required to be a fully functioning, empowered human being able to contribute to the conversation and move the moment forward.”

[from the article “America’s first gay rights group formed a century ago this year & you’ve probably never heard of it” in LGBTQ Nation]

A new kind of “boys night out”

Last night I went to the movie theatre (for the first time since COVID!) with one of my fellow baritone singers from the gay men’s chorus and his partner (both cis-men) and a cis-woman friend of theirs. After initial introductions and small talk, we went to get drinks & food for the show and while we were chatting the woman said to me, “Sorry for crashing your boys night out!” 

I guess a comment like that totally makes sense: her friends, the other two gay guys, are cis-men she knows and I, the newcomer, was introduced as a chorus member and I look like a man much more than I’m still able to realize. So she just made the assumption that I was a man and, probably, a gay man. 

Did she go as far as assuming that I’m cis? But maybe that doesn’t matter… it really shouldn’t: if I feel like a man, it doesn’t matter whether I’m cis or trans. 

Her playful comment, which was the clear indicator of an assumption based on looks & situation, baffled me for a brief moment: it still is disconcerting to me that the world may see me like a man without putting it in doubt, without me having to do anything to assert it or “prove” it. But then, past the momentary surprise, what I felt was a deep, extreme (albeit still partly incredulous) validation. 

It’s funny how validations can come in different flavors. There’s the ones from my trans/nonbinary/genderqueer friends; the ones from other close cis friends who know me well and see me as me; the ones from my beloved & loving “adventure buddies” (cis-het men); the ones from old friends (all of them but a few also cis-het) who have accepted my “new” gender identity without any problem or doubt whatsoever; the ones coming from strangers and the “outside world”. And then there are the validations coming specifically from the environment of gay men. The latter are the newest and least familiar to me. But they are just as important to me as the other ones because they validate a profound and essential part of my identity, i.e. the gay man in me.

This other baritone & I aren’t close friends, yet, but he is one of the half dozen people with whom I have some form of connection beyond choir, e.g. he & his partner came to my birthday party a couple months ago. Whatever we want to call this relationship between us — acquaintance, loose friendship — it is a new kind of relationship for me with new dynamics. With old friends I have safe, established, affectionate dynamics that go beyond our gender identities and/or sexual orientations. With my trans/nonbinary/genderqueer friends there’s the lovely, deep connection of our non-cis gender journey. With my buddies/cis-het men friends there’s a beautiful camaraderie and tonic male intimacy. The feelings, the dynamics in all of these relationships are wonderful, rich, fun, profound. And yet they are different from the dynamics I experienced last night at the movie theatre with two other gay men or what I experience with the chorus at large most Sunday evenings: the gay man in me is always there, in all my relationships, but it’s mirrored only when I’m out with the guys from the gay men’s chorus — which, I guess, makes sense! When I’m with folks from the gay men’s chorus I’m one of the gay guys, not “the gay guy among cis-het guys” nor the “gay boy in a group of pansexual genderqueer people”. 

All of my close friendships are extremely precious to me; I value and need and enjoy all of the different feelings or dynamics they involve — and they feel very familiar. But the ones with these gay men are still new to me, like a treasure chest to which I’ve only just found the key and of which I’m only starting to get a glimpse… and yet in there there are little mirrors, or fragments of mirrors, that can reflect back to me the gay man that I am in a light that may be different from what I’ve known so far.

About a foot in length

[Trigger warnings: surgical/anatomical details.]

A little over three weeks ago, I had a surgical procedure to cut out & remove the Fallopian tubes from my lower abdomen (salpingectomy). Each Fallopian tube is on average between 10 – 14 cm (3.9 – 5.5 in) in length, with an external diameter of ~1 cm (~0.39 in).

That’s almost half a foot of tissue removed from each side of my lower abdomen… that’s a big chunk… No wonder I had pain and aches in my abdominal fascia, radiating down into the ligaments of the pelvic area and thighs, for many days, even a couple weeks after the procedure… 

And amazing how all that could be removed through just two small incisions, each just over 1 cm in length, on either side of my belly, right above my hips… 

“Miss you, bro.”

“How are things going for you? Miss you, bro.”

Text message that one of my cis-het male climbing buddies sent me yesterday. 

It is messages like this one — messages and calls and visits from friends; walks&talks, lunch or coffee/tea, and movie nights with friends; all the gestures of affection and care, all the quality time together — that are finally allowing me to feel happy and warm and profoundly content with my relational life in a way that I hadn’t been able to feel since grad school. 

From the standpoint of relationships, I want nothing more. Or hardly anything — I still wish there were more opportunities for me to go on “adventures” with my buddies. Other than that, though, my relational needs are met: I don’t need, or want, romance (honestly, I don’t even understand it). And it’s such a liberation to finally realize and be able to say, “I’m not interested in romance” not because I’m still trying to get over a heartbreak or because I’m too busy or have other, all-absorbing goals in my life right now. 

No, I’m not interested in romance, as I never was, because I’m aro. And because as long as I can have — give & receive — enough love, affection, commitment, and quality time with my platonic friends, my relational needs are truly met.

“From Eden”

Playing in my mind this morning:

Babe
There’s something tragic about you
Something so magic about you
Don’t you agree?

Babe
There’s something lonesome about you
Something so wholesome about you
Get closer to me

No tired sighs, no rolling eyes, no irony
No ‘who cares’, no vacant stares, no time for me

Honey, you’re familiar like my mirror years ago
Idealism sits in prison, chivalry fell on its sword
Innocence died screaming, honey, ask me I should know
I slithered here from Eden just to sit outside your door

Babe
There’s something wretched about this
Something so precious about this
Where to begin?

Babe
There’s something broken about this
But I might be hoping about this
Oh, what a sin

To the strand a picnic plan for you and me
A rope in hand for your other man to hang from a tree

Honey, you’re familiar like my mirror years ago
Idealism sits in prison, chivalry fell on its sword
Innocence died screaming, honey, ask me I should know
I slithered here from Eden just to sit outside your door

Honey, you’re familiar like my mirror years ago
Idealism sits in prison, chivalry fell on its sword
Innocence died screaming, honey, ask me I should know
I slithered here from Eden just to hide outside your door

[From Eden” by Hozier]

Befriending my (new) body (again)

[Trigger warnings: dysphoria; scars & scar tissue.]

I’m feeling tender. But more aligned with myself. The dysphoria is finally easing its grip on my mind. 

The surgical glue has fully come off from the three incisions on my lower abdomen: one right under my belly-button and one on each side, just above my hip bones. The two incisions on the sides are a little red and irritated from the surgical glue and the one on the right still has some dry blood on it from the procedure, so I’m not rubbing them. But the one right under my belly-button isn’t irritated so I’ve been actually able to touch it more, running the tip of my finger along this thin, curved line, about 1.5 cm long, that almost looks like a little smile on my belly. The scar tissue is still hard so it feels weird, like a small, temporary implant in my belly-button. 

Three weeks after my salpingectomy & endometrial ablation, I am finally coming out of the dark tunnel of dysphoria. Slowly learning to love myself in this body as it is. Slowly befriending this body of mine, again, with these three additional scars. Being able to exercise and masturbate again has been crucial to regaining connection with, and acceptance of, my body. But even that isn’t always enough when the specter of dysphoria looms. 

It’s an ugly beast, dysphoria… 

I look at my body in the mirror and try to recognize it, try to recognize myself in it, try to recognize it as part of me. Sometimes I see it, I see myself, sometimes I don’t. In the past couple of weeks after my double procedure I’ve felt terribly disconnected from my body, uncomfortable in it, often unable to even look at it. But I’m slowly able to look at it, look at myself in the mirror again: this body with the new scars, with a new, concerning issue on my chest, with the new hairs growing on my forearms and cheeks. Some things I like, some I don’t, most of them I’ll probably have to accept anyway…

I’m trying to befriend these new scars, befriend these new, unpleasant shapes on my chest, befriend these new hairs… And maybe one day I’ll be able to actually love them, too… 

Protecting my boy as he steps into his own manhood

One of my closest nonbinary friends says gender is a social construct

So much of our identities in general depend on the social messaging that we get from the day we’re born. 

I was definitely given lots of toxic messaging as I was growing into myself — not simply for not being allowed to live in my true gender but also being taught in various ways that I wasn’t really worthy or lovable just as a human being but had to “earn love” and other such harmful messaging. But I also received a lot of positive, nurturing, supportive messaging: I was fortunate to meet many people along my path who saw & valued me, saw the real me, and supported me, nurtured me, encouraged me with unconditional love, thus teaching me to somehow value myself and find myself. 

As I step into my new year’s resolution to allow myself to be my own version of a man, I’m realizing that this is a very delicate phase for me: from my own boyhood to my own manhood. The messaging I give myself and receive from the outer world now, especially after such an emotionally hard surgery as the one I had a couple weeks ago, is crucial. 

In the past few years, as my gender journey has deepened and broadened and I have become more explicitly myself, I have been surrounded and supported by encouraging, loving friends and acquaintances who see me as I am and also see the potential me: having these parts of me reflected back to me by these living mirrors has been fundamental for me in gaining confidence to become & express who I really am as a whole. These people have not only reflected back to me the boy, the nonbinary transguy, the athlete, the scientist that I am: they have also reflected back to me the sense that I am worthy as a human being, as a whole

Generally, I have nothing against hookups or fuck-buddies: I’ve had that type of relationship a few times in my life when it was the right moment for me (& for the other persons involved). But now, as I slowly allow myself to be a man and, on top of that, as I learn to navigate the world of gay men that is still so new to me, I have to tread carefully around relationships. With my old friends and cis-het climbing or running buddies there’s a sense of safety, partly because we’ve known each other for a long time, and partly because I already know that type of interactions (platonic, athletic, intellectual, emotional). Whereas being seen not only as a man but as a handsome gay man by other gay men is totally new to me: I’m still in a boyhood phase there and the messaging I get from people in that world is going to be crucial for me now. So in this phase, in that world, relationships or prolonged interactions that give (the boy in) me the message “you’re hot” can be very toxic for me because they can make me feel objectified. The occasional comment, flirtatious or not, “you’re hot” is OK: it’s harmless and might be flattering for a fleeting moment or even affirming once in a while. But a comment of that type in the context of hooking up or being fuck-buddies risks building in me the image of myself as a sexual object with no further value, and that’s not OK for me now. 

(There’s no moral judgement here on hooking up or being fuck-buddies or feeling OK with being seen as a sexual object: there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with any of that, but it’s important to understand and respect if/when it feels OK for us, or not.)

Here’s where the man that is already in me needs to step up to protect the boy: here’s where I, as my own father, need to protect that boy in me as he slowly, gradually, vulnerably steps into his own manhood. 

Meeting people where they’re at

Yesterday I had planned to meet up & hang out with the gender-expansive gay guy from the chorus with whom I’ve hooked up in order to have a clarifying conversation about our “friendship”. I knew what I wanted to ask him, what I wanted to say, feeling the additional protection of my post-op restrictions that don’t allow me to have sex, yet. 

Well, my plans went to hell (in the good sense). We didn’t have the conversation. It didn’t feel like the right thing to do in that moment. As I was journaling in my diary planning this conversation a few days ago, I found myself writing, “I’m ready. Is he?” The truth is that I wasn’t ready, either, at least not yesterday. 

I’ve been feeling very vulnerable, delicate, fragile, even dysphoric and disconnected from my own body this past week. It’s been hard. Pain and anger and grief and real concern around my dysphoria have been haunting many hours of my days and nights for over a week. 

My decision to have the clarifying conversation with the gender-expansive gay guy was a rational and reasonable one. But yesterday what I needed was tenderness: I needed to be held, literally and figuratively, emotionally as much as physically, by a gay guy friend. I needed connection, validation, gender-affirmation, some gentle touch, not the rational dissecting of relationships. And he met me where I was yesterday. 

But I also met him where he was. He wouldn’t have been ready for such a conversation. Instead of helping to soften his protective shell or lower his defensive walls, it would have made them more impenetrable. Instead of allowing us both to have a sweet afternoon in “teenager mode” together, it would have soured things. 

We met each other where we were at. 

And I also met myself where I was, where I actually was emotionally yesterday, not theoretically on paper.

And now I’m realizing that has probably been one the most important things I’ve learned in relationships — or become more clearly aware of — in the past decade, and especially in the past few years. Most of the “relationships gone wrong” have been due to the parties involved being unable and/or unwilling to meet each other (and/or their own self) where each one was. Not just compromising: actually meeting each other emotionally. This holds for me for all types of close relationships, including with one’s own self.

I think I wasn’t taught this very important principle of close relationships, of meeting people somewhere that works for all parties involved, emotionally. I was taught to compromise, even to sacrifice, and had to fight and shake off so much of that toxic conditioning. Compromising from the practical standpoint is definitely important. But it’s not enough. It’s been a slow process for me to learn to meet people where they’re at, so that our close relationships may work. I’ve learned to do it thanks to sensitive people who have met me where I was, or am. I also learned to do it, partly, through my professional experiences teaching. I’ve learned it instinctively, by doing, by trial and error (oh, so many errors!). The more people met me where I was, the more I learned on an emotional, instinctive level, to do that in return. 

I didn’t see that at first, I just felt it, I felt something that felt better than in the past. Now I also see it. I still mess up sometimes, but at least I see it: this valuable key of healthy relationships.

The lost boy and the invisible man

… And maybe be myself. 

But who am I? 

The boy (in) me is lost. I am struggling terribly with my gender-identity. I’ve been seeing all these masc folks (cis-men, trans-men, nonbinary transmasc persons) and they all seem so much more masculine that me — their looks, their voices. 

I’m hating my voice. It sounds so “unmasculine”. To me it just sounds like a “low woman’s voice” and I hate it. 

Maybe it’s my recent surgery that is considered a “GYN procedure” — “gyn” being the Greek prefix for “woman”. 

I’m struggling to connect with my masculine side, I feel like I can’t find it, like it doesn’t even exist maybe… It feels gone, lost, invisible. 

Yesterday afternoon one of my binary transguy friends visited me. We don’t see each other very often but he’s a true friend and a lovely, sensitive, and very intelligent person. Our gender-identities as adults now differ a bit in that I feel nonbinary transmasc while he defines himself more as a transman (we both define ourselves also as “transguys” but probably with slightly different meanings). As children, though, we had very similar feelings: we both felt that we were boys, we both knew that we were boys, and we both suffered when those boys were stifled and not allowed to be or to grow up. We talked about our gender-identities again during our visit yesterday afternoon and I repeated something I often say, i.e. that I feel I’m a “boy”, I can go as far as saying that I am a “guy”, but I cannot see or feel myself as a “man”. And my friend made a very insightful comment, along the following lines: from the youngest age, we knew we were boys, and that original knowledge is still within us, so even now as adults our perception of our own masculinity can go as far as embracing the “boy”; but then, as we grew up, we weren’t allowed to turn into a “man” and so now, as adults, it’s so hard for us to embrace that possibility. 

I think he hit the nail on the head. I remember once this past summer I felt so deeply and intensely that I was a “man” that I even wrote about it here. I felt — & wrote — that I was “my own version of man”: a nonbinary trans man, but a “man” nonetheless — whatever “man” may mean.

For a fleeting moment, for a couple of days this summer, I was able to go that far, to allow myself to be “my own version of man”… 

… Where is he now?