Yesterday evening, I had the last class of a poetry course that I had been taking for the past eight weeks.
Yesterday afternoon, I posted that message on the bulletin board of my chorus to voice my difficulties around our current concert, coming out as aro.
And yesterday also marked the very end of direct communications with the gender-expansive gay guy from the chorus with whom I had hooked up.
Yesterday was a day of endings, of some closure.
These endings aren’t untimely, and maybe they’re not even completely unrelated — the two endings that have to do with chorus dymanics are definitely connected for me.
The end of the poetry course is hopefully going to lead directly into a new beginning as half a dozen of us in the group have eagerly agreed to keep in touch as “writing club” or “writing-accountability buddies” or “draft buddies”, and we exchanged email addresses at the end of class last night. Ending the ritual of a weekly evening class with the spring approaching might be nice for me from the practical viewpoint. And springtime might also encourage new writing dynamics with half of this group. I’m seeing this more as a shift.
With the chorus members, instead, it feels more like a breakup: the specific breakup with the gender-expansive gay guy with whom I had hooked up being a tassel within the same larger mosaic of something breaking for me within the gay men’s chorus as a whole.
I’ve been active in this chorus for six months now. The first month & a half was really hard, hellish at times. Then, it got better: gradually at first, and then almost suddenly, becoming really wonderful — a chosen family; a loving, supporting community; but maybe more importantly than anything for me, a space where I could have fun and be playful regularly, allowing me to explore my gender & my sexuality and to blossom in ways that I usually don’t. This happened within, and was allowed by, the chorus as a whole; but also, specifically, maybe almost symbolically, with the gender-expansive gay guy with whom I hooked up.
For about six months, so much of my energy and focus and thoughts and feelings revolved around the chorus — and for about three months, I also specifically put a lot of intentional effort into trying to build a relationship with the gender-expansive gay guy with whom I had hooked up. Some of that effort was rewarded in lovely, gratifying ways. A lot of it, though, wasn’t. I won’t say it was wasted, because it still served me as a lesson, as an experience. I learned a lot. But the main thing I feel I learned is that “I don’t really belong there” or that “it’s not really going to work for me with them”.
The climax was reached in February. For a few weeks starting at the end of January, I felt an incredible closeness and a real sense of possibility & connection with the chorus as a whole and with the gender-expansive gay guy in particular. I opened up, shared a lot of personal, vulnerable stuff, experimented more with my own gender expression — until the breakup, at the end of February, with the gender-expansive gay guy with whom I had hooked up and then the chorus retreat at the beginning of March. The latter marked the absolute climax for me of pushing my comfort zone with chorus members, exploring dynamics within the chorus as well as really experimenting with my own gender expression. It was A LOT. Maybe it felt “too close”, somehow “too much” for me. And now I feel the need to pull back.
What I have seen and experienced over the past four months since things got better for me within the chorus finally led to my post yesterday on the bulletin board announcing my aromanticism. In these past four months I feel like I’ve really tried to connect, and tried it in different ways, with members in the choir; but it hasn’t worked.
What was I hoping for from this group of people, beyond singing & performing together?
I was hoping to build those types of relationships that I cannot manage to build elsewhere but still need, i.e. friendships that in their dynamics include closer forms of physical intimacy and/or touch, and/or friendships whose base is simply “play & fun”, and/or friendships that would somehow introduce me into the “gay men’s world” (whatever that may mean).
But that hasn’t worked. Or maybe only the latter worked and I was, in fact, “introduced into the gay men’s world” and realized that it doesn’t suit me because I’m ace-aro…?
I can’t fully explain it now, but I know there’s a major ending here. I know that my breakup with the gender-expansive gay guy with whom I had hooked up and my decision yesterday to finally post to the chorus bulletin board about my aromaticism are linked, the two sides of the same coin.
I shall likely continue to sing with this chorus but I will also try to take the advice of one of my climbing buddies and see this group of people more as a “nice group of loving or supporting acquaintances” than as a pool for real friendship. As an opportunity for scheduled fun for three hours while we sing on Sunday evenings, and nothing more.
Maybe finding or building friendships that in their dynamics include closer forms of physical intimacy and/or touch, and/or friendships whose base is simply “play & fun” is something that I am unable to do and that I just need to make peace with…?