When I first started attending some online gender support groups for non-cis persons I was sometimes irritated by some trans-men and trans-women who claimed that being non-binary is often just a temporary phase towards “transitioning” fully to the other gender. This bothered me both from the point of view of principle because it seemed to reinforce a binary view of the world which I profoundly refuse to accept — and always have — and also from a personal viewpoint because it felt invalidating to my own experience.
I still believe those claims to be wrong because they’re fundamentally a generalization, applying some personal experiences (which are completely valid as far as those persons are concerned) to the rest of people — which I find to be very tricky, often even dangerous and/or wrong.
However, I do agree on one point, which is common to all non-binary/trans experiences I’ve been hearing and to many personal/human experiences overall: that all these experiences are processes that evolve and can change over time.
My own gender experience has been evolving immensely over the past year and a half and in a particularly fast and liberated way over the past six months or so, gaining speed as I feel more and more myself, leading me to have feelings or viewpoints and to make decisions for myself that I would never have imagined possible only a year or six months ago. And recently my own gender perception has been changing even more rapidly as if under the push of a strong acceleration.
When I hear stories of trans youth who are being supported in their gender identity, in the choice of their own pronouns and gender expression and even with name change already in their childhood or teenage years, I feel a surge of emotions: of course, I instantly feel happiness for them and the instinct to support and encourage them as well, even if from afar; I feel relief and optimism and gratitude for these corners of the world and this society that has evolved and improved and become more accepting and inclusive and open-minded, and maybe also wiser and kinder; but I also feel a profound, intense sadness to the point of often being moved to tears. Sadness for me: not for the adult me now who is enjoying their full gender identity and being able to express it and have it often accepted, recognized, respected and even loved; but for the child me who didn’t have that support or recognition or love. I end up crying for that little boy who suffered for decades. That little boy who wasn’t allowed to be.
I’m AFAB. I have been using “they” pronouns for a year now and identify as non-binary/trans-masculine and mostly feel like I’m a boy, but I also feel profoundly involved in feministic themes and affected literally at a visceral level when it comes to abortion and reproductive rights.
Recently, when I was in California to complete my move from there to here, I was able to have the two meetings I was hoping for the most, with the two young men to whom I really wanted to show my full non-binary/trans-masculine identity, to whom I wanted to say “I’m a boy!”
After the meeting and “coming out” with the first one, for the next couple of days I could hardly stop thinking “I wish I were a boy” with a deep longing that was tearing me apart, almost physically making my chest ache. And I instinctively increased my dose of testosterone (still micro-dosing) because of this strong desire to speed up the process of masculinization of my body to align it with my own internal gender identity faster — the longing was almost unbearable.
When I “came out” to the other one, he asked me if I was at this point using “he” pronouns instead of “they” pronouns. I replied that I’m still sing “they” pronouns, and that for the moment I think I might always use non-binary pronouns (despite using the masculine for myself in some languages/grammatical instances) because I was brought up and treated as a girl/woman for so long that I feel I cannot renounce that part of me. And when he said, “You look great and more like yourself than I’ve ever seen you”, I again felt a mix of strong and opposite emotions: happiness, on the one hand, because I do feel more like myself than I ever have and I finally love my body and identify with it more closely; but I also felt intense, almost sharp sadness and teared up, and I found myself saying, without even realizing it, instinctively: “I wish I had been born a boy. I wish I had been born male. No matter what I do, no matter how far I take this medical ‘transitioning’, I will never be like you because after all I was brought up like a girl, I was treated like a woman for so long: that conditioning is extremely deep and probably irreversible”.
So many memories of my childhood and youth are coming back to me, almost like a flooding river, lately, about my transgender identity manifesting itself at the youngest age. I have only one sibling, a sister who’s a couple years younger than myself, and we were always treated like a “pair”, like we had to be the same or always together — the “two beautiful little girls”. I hated it. I felt suffocated, with no space to be me. But it went even further than that: I often found myself thinking, and sometimes even saying aloud, that I could be the son that my father had never had. And when as teenagers my sister sometimes said she wished she had an older brother, my spontaneous reply would be, “I’m your older brother!”
How could it have been more explicit than that? How can I not grieve for that little boy, for that teenage boy who was not allowed to be?
I might use “they” pronouns for the rest of my life and stay mostly with a non-binary gender identity. But I’m also starting to think, more and more often, that maybe if I hadn’t been socialized as a female, i.e. if I hadn’t been brought up as a girl and then treated as a woman for so many years, my gender identity would be quite different and much more masculine. If I had been supported in my transgender identity earlier on, I think I might have become a man. Still a non-gender-conforming man, and very probably a gay man, and definitely just as unconventional and non-conforming as I am now and always have been. But probably my gender identity would have been more pronouncedly masculine.
And maybe the reason I’m feeling, and seeing myself, as a boy (instead of a man) now, despite being fully adult in age, is that I wasn’t allowed to be a boy when I needed to be one, in my youth, and I need to make up for that time, for those experiences, for those feelings now.