I’m visiting one of my friends from the Ragnar race (& his wife) in Salt Lake City. These people are not queer but they are great allies, very open-minded and full of relatives & other friends who are queer. This couple is also going through a period of renewed self-discovery and self-definition, for reasons quite different from my own but that nonetheless made the connection with this new running buddy at Ragnar instantaneous.
With the group of people at Ragnar I was very much in my masculine identity (using only “he” pronouns), very much “one of the guys”. So this new friendship started on those terms, with those dynamics, and it feels good to me also because of that: I’m visiting one of my trail running buddies and he & I are exploring the local mountains together as guys. Both because of this friendship being recent, new, and because of it having started on a “male footing”, there’s something very liberating and refreshing about it, as it allows me to experiment & explore my masculine sides with someone who knows me “just as a boy”. And as a “gay boy”.
So going to a gay bar for my first time ever with my trail running buddy (& his wife) the other night felt good as it fits into this particular phase of exploring my masculinity & defining my way of being masculine. It also has the advantage of happening in a city where nobody knows me so I feel a little less social pressure.
Still, the experience at the gay bar the other night was very intense and quite nerve-racking for me.
Overall, it was good and I want to do it again, I can’t wait to do it again. But I also feel nervous about doing it again because it wasn’t easy.
The cis-hetero-normative couple I am visiting as well as some other cis-hetero friends of mine were very surprised that I had never been to a gay bar before and they even made comments like, “Even I have been to a gay bar” or “Gay bars are so much more fun than straight bars” (or was it even worse and they said “normal bars”? I cannot remember). These comments didn’t sit well with me. I know the intentions were good but they’re missing the point — several of the most important points for me, actually. (And, on the other hand, I would like to ask: “Why would you go to a gay bar as a straight person?” or “Why do you, as a cis-hetero person, find gay bars more fun than straight bars?”)
As to me, it’s not only gay bars that I’d never been to before: I don’t go to bars, period. I never really had a reason to go to bars, whether straight or gay. I don’t like to drink and I don’t like crowds or loud places, and I don’t like having to shout to have a conversation. I enjoy dancing very much so I’ve been to clubs several times throughout my life, including very gay clubs in Colorado which have been fun experiences — but I go just for the dancing.
Moreover, even if I had been to a gay bar before, going to a gay bar now, now that I’m living fully and openly in my true identity as non-binary gay trans-guy, it would the first time for me at a gay bar anyway: the first time for this gay trans-boy at a gay bar. And it’s precisely this that makes it such a huge step and made it such an intense and in many ways nerve-racking experience the other night: I walked into that space being perceived as a (handsome) young man. If I had walked into that place even only a year or two ago, I would have been perceived very differently: two or three years ago, I still would have been perceived as a “woman” walking in. Now I am perceived as a man walking in.
I know I keep writing about this here but it’s hard to convey in words how much this fact turns the world upside down, how much getting used to it takes, how much rewiring of the brain it involves.
For so many years I can remember wishing people would see me as a boy, as a guy. I remember how much I tried to pass as a boy, as a guy, with baggy clothes, short hair, and masculine postures. Sometimes it even worked, and it felt incredibly wonderful, but it was fleeting moments that became more and more rare, until they eventually disappeared and I (the “old me”) settled with being a “badass girl who did boys’ stuff”.
But now that wish has come true. Now I walk into a store, a restaurant, an airport, an office, my climbing gym, the crag or trail, and I am perceived as a guy.
It changes everything.
And in places where physical aspect counts or is noticeable, like gyms or bars, I am perceived as an attractive guy. Which for me adds a whole lot of layers, maybe from my own personal baggage, which aren’t easy to carry or shake off.
And if I specifically walk into a gay bar, I am walking into a space where I’m trying to belong, a place that feels aligned to my true identity while also being new and scary and not completely acknowledged even to myself yet. I’m walking into a space where I feel I am one of them and yet I also still worry that I don’t fully belong or that “they might think I don’t belong”. And on top of it, I’m walking into a place where the physical aspect of people counts or, at least, is one of the first things that is noticed; a place where people will look around and stare and make moves on other persons. Of course, part of why I want to start going to gay bars is to see if I can meet other gay guys there and see how it feels. But I’m not used to this kind of environment and interactions of this type feel at least partly uncomfortable to me. Whether it’s simply because I’m shy or not used to these places, or whether it’s my neurodivergent brain, or whether it’s the impostor syndrome related to my gender journey, I don’t know how to behave in a (gay) bar. Yes, it is flattering to walk in and realize that guys are registering my presence and looking at me as a handsome/desirable young man: it’s flattering and affirming. But it’s also uncomfortable and scary as hell. What do I do? What do I say if someone comes up to me? Will they “see through me” and realize I’m trans and not be OK with it?
This confusion, these doubts and fears are very real for me.
Going to gay bars for me isn’t just “fun” as it may be for many people. Going to gay bars for me now is yet another step in my self-determination, in the exploration of my gender identity & sexual orientation; it’s an extremely important and delicate new phase in my own journey, in my growth, in the (re)claiming of myself.